B3 Golf / Learn
Learn with Philippe
Feel Comes From Mechanics: The Right Way to Learn Golf
By Philippe Bonfanti, PGA Advanced Coach and TrackMan University Master
Should you learn golf by finding a feel that works, or by learning the right mechanics first? Learn the mechanics first. Feel doesn't create good mechanics: good mechanics create feel. Once you can repeat the correct movement, notice what it feels like and use that sensation as your reference point for repeating it.
What does "good mechanics create feel" mean?
One of the biggest misconceptions in golf is that players should "find a feel that works" and build their game around it. It sounds nice, but it's backwards.
When you're learning a skill in golf, whether it's your backswing, your impact position or your putting stroke, you first need to learn the principle. That means understanding and executing the correct mechanic: the movement or position that produces a desirable outcome.
Only once you can perform that mechanic consistently should you start asking, "What does this feel like to me?" The feel comes second. It's the result of a good movement, and it becomes your way of finding that movement again.
Why is chasing a feel the wrong way round?
There are three reasons.
- Feel is personal. The same correct movement can feel completely different from one golfer to another. A feel that works for your playing partner may mean nothing to you, or send you somewhere else entirely.
- Guessing at feels without a solid mechanic often locks in bad habits. If you're repeating a sensation without knowing what it produces, you may simply be getting better at the wrong movement.
- Principles are universal. While feels differ, good mechanics don't change. They're grounded in physics and geometry that work for everyone.
That last point runs through all of my coaching. Every golfer is unique, but we are all governed by the same laws of physics and geometry, and we all swing clubs that are built with set angles. Style can vary. Even the world's best players don't all set up the same way. The principles underneath stay the same.
What counts as a "mechanic" in the golf swing?
A mechanic is a specific movement or position that produces a result you want. In my lessons these have simple names, so they're easy to remember. Examples include "weight forwards", "hands in", "arms straight" and "steady head".
Each one is tied to a job the swing has to do. Weight forwards, for example, helps you hit the ground in front of the ball for solid contact. Hands in helps you create power and approach the ball from the inside. Because each mechanic has a clear purpose, you can check whether you're doing it by looking at what the ball and the ground tell you, rather than relying on how it felt.
Behind all of them sit the three things every good swing has to do: hit the ground in the same spot, generate sufficient power, and control the curvature of the ball. A mechanic earns its place by helping with one of those three.
Why can't you always trust how a swing feels?
Feel and reality don't always match. A movement can feel like a big change and turn out to be tiny, or feel the same while something quite different is happening.
Here's a simple test. If you're a player who practises, you should be improving and your handicap should be coming down. If it isn't, that's a sure sign you're either not prioritising the right things, or not executing them in the way you think you are. The second of those is the gap between feel and reality.
This is why measuring helps. When you can see what the club and ball are actually doing, you can link a movement to a real result. Once the numbers and the ball flight match what you're trying to achieve, you can begin to internalise the feel for the correct movement.
How should you learn a new move?
Next time you're practising, work in this order:
- Learn and execute the correct mechanic.
- Pay attention to the sensations that come with it.
- Use that personal feel as a reference point to repeat the correct movement, not to invent one.
The order matters. Step two only means something once step one is in place. If you skip straight to the sensations, you have nothing reliable to anchor them to.
Why does this matter under pressure?
Great players chase principles. Once they've nailed the principle, the feel follows, and that gives them something reliable to come back to under pressure.
A feel you've built on top of a sound mechanic is one you can trust when it counts, because you know what it's connected to. A feel you've invented has nothing underneath it, which is exactly when it tends to let you down.
Try it at your next session
Pick one move you're working on, then:
- Hit a few shots where you alternate between doing the move correctly and incorrectly. This gives you a definite understanding of how the move affects the ball flight.
- On the correct ones, notice what the move feels like to you.
- Use that feel only as a reminder of the correct movement. If the ball flight stops matching, go back to the mechanic, not the feel.
FAQ
Should beginners learn golf by feel?
Start with the principle. Learn the correct mechanic first, and once you can perform it consistently, the feel will follow.
Why does a tip that works for my friend not work for me?
Feel is personal. The same correct movement can feel completely different from one golfer to another, so borrowing someone else's feel rarely works.
Is there one correct golf swing?
Styles vary, and even the best players don't all set up the same way. The underlying principles are the same for everyone, because they're grounded in physics and geometry.
How do I know if I'm really doing the move?
Check the result rather than the sensation. If you're practising but not improving, you may not be executing the move the way you think you are, and measuring what the club and ball do will show you.
If you'd like help finding the right mechanics for your swing, you can book a lesson with Philippe at B3 Golf, at Iford Golf Centre in Bournemouth.